Test & Measurement: Squashing the blues

Dieter Mahnken and Ute Philipp from Rohde & Schwarz explain how effective RF and audio testing of Bluetooth components can be done with just one instrument
Nearly all new vehicles today offer Bluetooth hands-free equipment. The Bluetooth connection between smartphone and infotainment system can also be used for numerous other applications. The individual components must undergo RF and audio tests to ensure that the headset, speakers, infotainment system and smartphone all work seamlessly with each other.
During the development of new radio components, complex and often costly tests are required. These tests should be reproducible and fast to execute. Certification by officially approved test houses is also necessary to use and sell these components on the market. These certifications are cost-intensive.
With suitable test and measurement equipment, engineers can perform precertification tests in their own laboratory to determine whether components will be certified by the test houses. Wideband radio communications testers exist for such precertification testing and are approved by the Bluetooth Special Interest Group (SIG). Such testers can handle RF and audio testing during development, production and service. Users can simulate realistic conditions for networks such as Bluetooth, WLAN, LTE-A, WCDMA and GSM.
What began with the Bluetooth headset has led to numerous additional functions that can be transferred from a smartphone via Bluetooth to the infotainment system and its speakers. Bluetooth is a radio transmission medium that is primarily used for the transmission of audio data and for control purposes. Users can make phone calls via the Bluetooth connection and upload their contact lists to the infotainment system. They can also play music or podcasts from a smartphone and listen to it over the vehicle's speakers.
Some systems can read out text messages as audio. And in some vehicles, drivers can operate their smartphone apps over the vehicle's infotainment system when their smartphones connect to the system. Such apps include a navigation system or an info service for traffic reports, weather forecasts or hotels, petrol stations and restaurants in the vicinity.
Audio transmission
The audio Bluetooth transmission is based on Bluetooth Classic specifications from the Bluetooth SIG. Due to the effective data throughput of 0.7 to about 2.1Mbit/s and the adaptive frequency hopping (AFH) transmission method, Bluetooth Classic is a short-range radio technology for distances up to 10m that is robust even in noisy environments.
Today's widespread Bluetooth Low Energy technology, also called Bluetooth Smart, has been around since Bluetooth specification 4.0, which came out in 2010. However, it is currently not used for audio transmissions. The two Bluetooth technologies have been continually developed in parallel.
Bluetooth Classic operates with a synchronous link for voice transmission (synchronous connection-oriented or SCO) and an asynchronous link for data transmission (asynchronous connectionless or ACL). Audio signals can be transmitted with different Bluetooth profiles for the synchronous link.
The hands-free profile (HFP), for example, transmits audio signals from the microphone near the driver via the infotainment system to the smartphone and back. For voice transmissions in HFP, the continuously variable slope delta modulation (CVSD) voice codec with a maximum transmission rate of 64kbit/s is used.
The advanced audio digital profile (A2DP) is used for stereo playback of music stored on a device with a Bluetooth interface.
According to the Bluetooth standard, A2DP sources must support the low complexity sub-band coding (SBC) audio codec, which does not require a licence. During SBC-based transmission of music from the smartphone, the device first decompresses the music, which is usually saved in compressed form, and then compresses it using the SBC algorithm for Bluetooth transmission. SBC coding can have a bit rate of up to 345kbit/s. This is high enough that any receiver loss is no longer in the audible range and good audio quality can be ensured. The smartphone sends this Bluetooth sound stream via ACL to the infotainment system, which then transfers it via cable to the speakers.
Audio measurements
For Bluetooth transmission of sound information, it is crucial that the acoustic signal be transmitted with as high a quality as possible, without noise and dropouts. For this reason, Bluetooth headsets as well as microphones and speakers and the infotainment system's associated radio components undergo RF tests to ensure error-free Bluetooth transmission.
The sound also needs to be played back in good audio quality. This is checked using audio analyses that test the frequency response, total harmonic distortion and noise and also offer a detailed spectrogram of the signal.
Due to the low frequencies in the audio range, the settling times of filters and other components can play a role. Therefore, the Bluetooth RF tester should be able to adjust to the frequency of the test signal to perform measurements as quickly as possible. This applies to level measurements and to complex analyses such as total harmonic distortion plus noise (THD+N).
A Bluetooth tester must be able to establish a complete Bluetooth connection to the device under test (DUT) via the SCO or ACL link. The tester should also support the relevant codecs and profiles for all audio transmissions. The following codecs and profiles are currently required for testing purposes: the narrowband CVSD codec, the broadband mSBC codec in conjunction with the hands-free profile and the broadband SBC codec with the A2DP.
For precise audio analysis, the tester should also be able to send commands to set the level of the microphone and speakers. These level settings are specified in the Bluetooth SIG audio video remote control profile (AVRCP). All this is assured if the Bluetooth tester being used is approved by the Bluetooth SIG.
Audio tests
A wideband radio communications tester uses an integrated two-channel audio generator to check the Bluetooth audio quality. There are various measurement procedures. Via the multitone mode, a developer can define up to 20 sounds for each audio channel (level and frequency) and measure the associated frequency responses.
In single-tone mode, the following parameters can be specified for a sine signal: audio level, frequency, signal-to-noise and distortion ratio (SINAD), THD and THD+N. There are also several filters that can be selected for the audio measurement.
Stereo music transmission
Stereo transmission of music is carried out via the A2DP with SBC coding and uses the broadband ACL for data transmission. Bluetooth devices that support A2DP must correctly process signals from SBC codecs. Tests with SBC-coded signals based on ACL also show whether or not the DUT correctly transmits longer packets. It is also practical if the Bluetooth tester can analyse and play all SBC codec modes such as dual, mono, stereo and joint stereo (dual mode for high-quality transmissions).
Headset testing
Testing the microphone of a Bluetooth headset also involves testing the headset's audio input amplifier and A-D converter. The Bluetooth tester's audio generator produces the audio signal that is transmitted to the microphone under test via a reference speaker. The microphone then transmits this audio signal to the tester's audio analyser via a Bluetooth link. The tester measures this signal and compares it to the original outgoing signal.
Testing a headset speaker includes testing the headset's D-A converter and output amplifier. The Bluetooth tester's audio generator produces an audio signal and transmits it to the headset via a Bluetooth link. There it is amplified and converted to an acoustic signal via a sound converter. This signal is picked up by a reference microphone and sent via a reference amplifier to the tester's audio analyser where it is displayed and evaluated. Audio tests on the Bluetooth module of an infotainment system are performed in much the same way.
Relevant RF tests
When developing a device with a Bluetooth interface, functional tests, interoperability tests and the range are relevant. The receiver sensitivity and transmit characteristics of the components are crucial for the range.
To measure the transmit characteristics of a Bluetooth component, the developer must be able reproducibly to determine characteristic values such as power, spectrum, frequency accuracy, frequency drift, frequency deviation and the modulation index calculated from these values. Receiver sensitivity is another important parameter for a Bluetooth device. This parameter is measured using an artificially impaired signal generated by the Bluetooth tester (dirty transmitter).
Bluetooth module receiver tests are performed by sending highly accurate data from a precise generator to the receiver. The data are analysed either by having the receiver return the bit sequence or by using an external control PC.
Numerous, additional RF signalling tests as well as spectrum measurements on newly developed Bluetooth components will be required until they receive Bluetooth certification from the Bluetooth SIG. In addition to the described audio measurements, communications testers can support all Bluetooth RF tests cases for prequalification purposes for Bluetooth Classic and Bluetooth Low Energy up to the latest specification five.
Other radio technologies
Users can expand testing to include other radio technologies. Many devices support more than just Bluetooth. They also support WLAN, GNSS and/or various other mobile technologies such as LTE, LTE-A, WCDMA and GSM. When WLAN and Bluetooth components use the same antenna, the developer can test both radio technologies with one test configuration.
If the tester is equipped with the appropriate hardware and software options, it is possible to test all integrated radio modules of a component up to precertification. This allows the developer to check whether and to what extent the individual radio modules affect each other and to define any necessary measures. This test is called the coexistence test.
Dieter Mahnken and Ute Philipp are product managers at Rohde & Schwarz
