Guest blog: Fact and fiction: The hybrid lie

Aidan McClean

Aidan McClean from UFODrive calls for hybrid cars to be banned

Hybrid cars are more than outdated and pointless; they are holding back to the transition to clean transport and net-zero.

They briefly had a place, back in the 1990s, in demonstrating electric technology, but now have no place in the world, and I would go as far as to say that they should be banned along with combustion engines as soon as possible.

The reason I propose such a draconian measure is because hybrid cars are not only doing very little to help, they are actually slowing the transition to zero emission fully electric cars. This is due to two main reasons; first, they are an unnecessary distraction for consumers and, secondly, they are blocking infrastructure that should only be used for fully electric cars.

 

Environment

Many people want to drive more efficient, and therefore more fuel friendly machines and, at first glance, a hybrid appears to be the answer to both. You will never have to worry about running out of range, because you still have an internal combustion engine in a hybrid car, and you can feel good about yourself because you are reducing your emissions, right? Wrong.

Three of the most popular plug-ins in 2020 all emitted more CO2 than advertised when tested in the real world, according to research by Transport & Environment, and this matches previous research on older models.

With a plug-in hybrid (PHEV), you charge usually a very small battery that gives limited range, typically less than 50km on electric, and the rest of the time you’re on petrol. So, although you could say that fifty clean kilometres is better than nothing at all, as they have to carry around the weight of the internal combustion engine and its fuel, the effects are more than negligible.

 

Placebo

Some might say they may be marginally better for the environment. Even if we say for argument’s sake that this is true, it is their position within the market and the impact on the consumer that makes their overall impact still negative.

They are a placebo, and an unnecessary distraction from going full electric and seeing real, measurably positive impacts for carbon emissions and therefore the climate. If people go hybrid, they think they may not need to go fully electric as they are doing their bit, without doing very much at all. Although the warm feeling of complacency when you make the ethical choice is no bad thing, when this feeling is misplaced, it just distracts and delays from significant, valuable changes.

Furthermore, it has become quite common for people to state that they will try hybrid first before going full electric due to the irrational fear of range of electric cars. Research conducted by Nissan showed that 97% of EV drivers found the switch "as expected" or "easier", and 89% believe ditching diesel or petrol was the right decision. This means that, ultimately, the hybrid option is reducing or delaying peoples’ desires to go full electric.

 

Infrastructure

There is only a limited amount of electric charge points out there, and even less of those rapid charging points so vital to the electrification of our roads and motorways, and therefore the green transition. When EVs use charge points, they are using what limited resources real EVs need.

Range anxiety is a common, and often misplaced, fear of going electric. Building more charge points is vital, and we don’t nearly have enough, but if they are being used by cars that have an internal combustion engine, and let’s not forget have negligible, if any, positive impacts on the environment, they are reducing the operational capacity of our electric infrastructure. Every time a potential EV owner who’s looking at going electric sees charging points taken, they may think to themselves “best not get an EV yet”.

 

Conclusion

• Fiction: Hybrid cars are better for the environment, and a good necessary transition to electric cars.

• Fact: Hybrids offer just a tiny, inconsequential positive climate impact. Hybrid cars are slowing the transition to full EVs by misleading consumers and blocking public charging infrastructure necessary for full battery electric cars. Hybrid car technology is now irrelevant.

 

Aidan McClean co-founded the all-digital all-electric car rental compan, UFODrive.

aidanmcclean.com

Recommend to Colleagues: