Vehicle Newtorks: Ethernet versus Most

Steve Rogerson looks at the debate about which networking technologies will be used for future automotive infotainment systems
A year ago, ABI Research predicted that the use of Ethernet in new vehicles would grow from just one per cent in 2014 to around 40% by 2020 thanks to the publishing of the 100Mbit/s BroadR-Reach automotive Ethernet standard in 2011. If that is accurate then that spells serious worry for the Most standard in its quest to become dominant for infotainment applications.
Most has already had success in being implemented by car makers in all areas of the world and it has responded to the perceived threat of Ethernet with Most 150, which brings with it a bandwidth of 150Mbit/s and an embedded Ethernet channel for carrying IP-based packet data.
But Dominique Bonte, vice president at ABI Research, said when the report was launched last year: “The emergence of drive-by-wire, the explosion of in-vehicle sensors for adas and automated driving, and the adoption of connected infotainment, pose new challenges for in-vehicle networking technologies in terms of cost, bandwidth, cable harness weight and complexity. Ethernet is now being considered as a replacement for legacy bus protocols such as Most and Flexray by car OEMs including BMW and Hyundai.”
Since then, in May 2014, Hyundai announced that it would be using Most 150 in its Genesis model. And earlier last year Mercedes-Benz put its weight behind Most 150 for its S class vehicles.
"Most 150 has successfully accomplished series development for the next Mercedes-Benz infotainment generation, with fully qualified series production parts available for all key components," said Peter Haeussermann, head of telematics at Daimler. "Most 150 has recently been first implemented in the brand-new generation of the S class. After that, the technology will be rolled out onto all other Mercedes-Benz car lines, step by step."
Henry Muyshondt, administrator for the Most standard, said: “Even BMW will be using Most for a long time.”
He said this was despite the car maker presenting at many of the Ethernet symposiums and conferences plugging Ethernet.
“They are enthusiastic about Ethernet technology and want to make their opinion known,” said Muyshondt, who is also senior marketing manager at Microchip Technology. “They want to convince others to see things their way.”
One of the problems though he believes is that when people talk about Ethernet for automotive applications they are not always referring to the same thing.
“There is a lot of discussion on automotive Ethernet,” he said. “But people use Ethernet to mean many different things. Some people mean a specific frame format, others don’t really mean Ethernet but they mean IP communications – that is what most people mean.”
Ethernet, he said, really refers to the IEEE 802.3 standard that defines the physical and data-link layers used to connect computers. It specifies the four twisted-pair category-five wires and the electronics they connect to on a typical office or home computer, along with a particular format for a packet of information. It does not refer to the higher communications protocols above the physical layer, such as the various internet protocols and other communications mechanisms used in the IT communications world.
It also does not refer to such things as Wifi, Bluetooth or other networking physical connections, even when those connections use packets of information similar to those used in a proper Ethernet system.
“There have not been many cars with an Ethernet physical layer in them,” he said. “BMW has a camera system that uses this technology. But people are still looking at various network technologies and you can’t say what will happen after 2020. Most car companies have different guys looking at different technologies.”
The Most standard, he said, supported Ethernet communications and this was being used by car makers such as Daimler and Audi; the Audi A3 was the first car to use Most 150 and the car maker has been using earlier versions of Most since 2002.
Some car companies have yet to come down in favour of any networking technology. Ford is a good example of this.
“Ford has not used a network on its entertainment systems,” said Muyshondt. “Everything is together in one big box. They haven’t moved to networking technology. They have looking at alternatives but I don’t know of any decision as what they will use. Chrysler is the same.”
In the Far East, the likes of Kia and Toyota as well as Hyundai are using Most. Nissan are considering all the technologies. Muyshondt said though that one Japanese car maker will soon be making an announcement about its use of Most.
“I don’t know of any that have said they will not use Most,” he said.
In Europe, most of the German car makers are using Most on some vehicles. In France, Renault and Peugeot have not committed to a standard. British car makers Aston Martin and Jaguar Land Rover are also among those using Most.
The proponents of Ethernet say, as it is a technology used in lots of different industries, that will make it easier to use. But Muyshondt said using it in the physical layer could lead to a lot of problems in cars.
“You can’t use the standard category five Ethernet cable,” he said. “Something special has to be developed and it is a challenge especially at the higher speeds to make it work. There will be many solutions to this problem. The standard will not be the same as what everyone else is using and that takes away the main argument for Ethernet.”
He said though that IP communications would be needed at the higher level both for internal communications and connecting cars to the cloud.
“Here is does make sense that we use that type of technology,” he said, “and Most already supports that. But at the physical layer there are still a lot of challenges for Ethernet.”
He said at the higher speeds there was still a lot of discussion about whether Ethernet would be robust enough for automotive applications.
“There is a lot of discussion about one or the other,” he said. “In reality, there will be both in some vehicles such as the BMW X5. They use Ethernet for the camera and Most for other communications. So it is not either-or but both. Most already supports all the things that Ethernet wants to do.”
