On the wire

Vehicles such as the BMW 3 series can contain up to 3km of cable

Reinhold Blank from Zuken explains why data formats matter for cutting wiring harness costs

Data exchange is a hot topic for car manufacturers. Developments in this area have opened up the market for collaboration and forced price competition, and they have also enabled design and collaboration efficiency.

In the domain of wiring systems, a data exchange standard has been established by the German automotive industry over the past ten years. Called KBL (Kabel Baum Liste), it has had an impact on different stakeholders.

Ask any automotive manufacturer today where they look to make unit cost savings in their vehicles, and the wiring system will surely top their list. As one of the most expensive and heaviest system components, with the highest degree of variance, it poses a challenge that must be approached from every angle.

Consider an average premium mid-class vehicle such as a Mercedes C class or BMW 3 series. Vehicles such as these contain up to 3km of cable with a total weight of up to 100kg. Given these volumes, even modest cost savings can give manufacturers a clear competitive edge when applied to a platform of millions of cars per year.

 

KBL format

A significant factor in recent times that has helped reduce cable manufacturing costs, and led to more efficient collaboration, is the development of the standardised KBL data exchange format. KBL is defined as VDA 4964 and is based on the ISO standard Step AP212 (ISO 10303-212).

Created by an industry-wide collaboration (a VDA working group in Germany), the format brought an end to the phenomenon of OEMs being tied directly to wiring harness manufacturers, and the suppliers to OEMs. In that set-up, suppliers operated in a mostly closed system where they had to base their entire process chain on the processes of their respective OEMs. Generally, they could only use the processes, data and tools for the electrical system development process of their manufacturers, since there was little or no support for data exchange from within the manufacturers’ closed systems with those of their competitors.

By creating a standardised language with which the entire process chain could communicate, KBL blew open this closed market with opportunities for OEMs to work with multiple harness manufacturers. And, most importantly, it allows OEMs to realise cost savings as they benefit from global sourcing to drive down cost, as with their other components.

The standard has also opened up business opportunities for suppliers because they can now tender and deliver to OEMs that they were previously excluded from working with due to their process specialisation. 

 

Openness

When the standardisation was initiated more than 15 years ago, most stakeholders expected that they would only need to agree on a common data format. But they soon discovered that if partners no longer work side-by-side sharing the detail of their processes, it has a serious impact on data quality and processing.

It is not sufficient that one party (OEM) throws data over the fence and expects the supplier on the other side to understand it and incorporate it into their in-house processes to manufacture and supply wire harnesses. This sounds simple, but it’s a complex task in practice.

It is precisely this that led not only to the standardisation of data exchange but also to closer data development practices in the German wire harness industry. So the KBL standard was developed further to its current version 2.3.

This has created another issue. Tool manufacturers lost the stability that came from knowing their OEM was tied to them for the foreseeable future, as they couldn’t integrate with any other tools. And the tool vendors used to know that all related suppliers had to use the same tools. With the new standards, there is more competition for the tool vendors and they have to compete on quality for every stage of the process chain.

For the user, this means that as well as the cost benefit of competition, they have the advantage of being able to choose the best-in-class tool for each process stage.

Once the data are supplied in KBL format, each design stage can be performed using specialised tools. KBL therefore acts as a virtual data backbone for the overall process chain, which generates real benefits.

 

Limitations

Although the KBL format has produced real benefits for the automotive industry, there are limitations. The biggest one is that the raw KBL file does not transfer all the data needed for producing or inspecting a harness product. This means the graphical representation – the explicit harness drawing – must be included to specify the complete harness product. Information that is not supported in the KBL format includes, for example, geometric dimensioning and tolerancing, textual or graphical information, and assembly instructions on the drawing, such as position markers that show the spatial direction of a bundle.

There are also dialects of the KBL format that various OEMs have created as workarounds for details not covered with KBL.

 

Towards VEC

These limitations in KBL drove the VDA project group to start work on a new format to meet the challenges of next generation automobiles, so the VEC (Vehicle Electrical Container) standard was conceived.

First published in 2011, the format allows for an extended electrological description, meaning a detailed documentation of the components used is enabled and the exact description of the topology enabled. VEC represents a significant improvement on KBL.

Some of VEC’s key technical features are:

  • Vendor-specific extensions of the data model, frequently referred to as dialects, are omitted. This gives the supplier more choice.
  • Deeper integration of geometric data means additional drawings are not needed to complement KBL files.
  • The entire cable harness is described digitally so the whole process chain can now be fully digitised.

As one might expect, driving industry-wide change in such a fundamental part of the automotive production chain takes time and care. So to support users during the transition phase of the emerging VEC format, there is what is known as a package process, in which the KBL file forms the core of a package to which the harness drawing is added and linked as an SVG graphic. Both are then zipped into a container – the harness container for vehicle (HCV) file – and can be transferred as a single file.

This process has been used successfully by several OEMs for a number of years. It supports a combination of tools from different vendors within one end-to-end process.

 

Future benefits

The Ecad Implementer Forum (Ecad-IF) working group of the Prostep iViP Association supports the implementation of interfaces based on the VEC and KBL standards. Vendors are driving the deployment of the VEC standard in tools related to wiring system design and engineering processes, based on user priorities.

By standardising and expanding the digital description of harness products, VEC will help build on the changes enabled by KBL in reducing the constraints on the automotive industry, which means that competition between suppliers will further increase. Opportunities will also open up for cooperation with additional OEMs that have not previously been within reach for technical or geographical reasons.

Through the systematic digitisation of harness documentation, the collaborative development process will become even more efficient, which in turn will open up savings potential for all parties.

Reinhold Blank is business director for automotive at Zuken

www.zuken.com

 

Recommend to Colleagues: 

Comments

No Avatar
violintec (not verified) on Thu, 03/06/2021 - 12:27

Very informative post. Violin Technologies Cable harnesses offer a compact, intelligent yet simple way to bind numerous associated wires and cables into a cable harness. Visit https://www.violintec.com/