Power Technologies: Fluid approach

A cool way to manage batteries in electric and hybrid cars is explored by Alexej Dens from 3M
Since batteries represent a high proportional cost of any electric or hybrid car – both at purchase point and on-going use by the customer – it is no surprise that ways in which to improve management of this area is such a focus for today's vehicle electronics designers. In turn, thermal management of battery packs is increasingly in the spotlight, since temperature has a huge impact on the performance, safety and life of the battery pack.
Any temperature variation can lead to electrically unbalanced modules, lower performance and shortened battery life.
Ideally, variations of temperature should be minimal across and between battery cells; too low a temperature can reduce energy output, while excessive heat can reduce cell life. That is why there has been increased interest in how to improve liquid immersion cooling for managing the heat generated by batteries.
Liquid immersion cooling has been shown to be generally more cost-effective than air cooling, as well as being a fast and effective way to remove heat safely from batteries without any damage. It is also an area that has gone through some considerable technical advances in recent years.
That is not to say that other forms of cooling – whether air or thermal interface materials – do not have a role to play in vehicle electronics. Indeed, there are instances where the latter is ideal for heat management, but as far as batteries in electric vehicles are concerned, there is a general consensus that liquid immersion cooling has a role to play in the current and future development of battery design.
So let's look more closely at the various liquid cooling options available, with their uses and relative pros or cons. The main sub-categories are water-glycol mixtures, oil-based and specialty fluids based on advanced chemicals. Regardless of type, there are certain attributes to look for:
- Thermo-physical properties – heat transfer liquids remove heat by convection so factors such as the coefficient of expansion, high density, low viscosity and low surface tension are beneficial.
- Direct contact – a high dielectric strength makes fluids good insulators and suitable for direct contact with power electronic systems.
- Temperature range – this depends on the application, but typically a low freezing point is desirable, while the atmospheric boiling point is chosen in relation to the upper operating temperature.
- Longevity – chemical and thermal stability for the lifetime of the component or device being cooled.
- Good materials compatibility – non-corrosive behaviour with electronic components as well as compatibility with a wide range of plastics.
- Cost of ownership – across the lifetime of the component or device it is supporting. For instance, complexity has an impact on cost; some systems require fewer components, such as the removal of the need to have a separate pump.
- Sustainability – is the coolant subject to any current or forthcoming environmental, health and safety legislation or restrictions?
- Low or zero flammability – an obvious requirement in electric vehicle design.
- Safety – Is the coolant toxic and safe to handle?
- Weight – HFEs (hydro fluoro ether) are heavy but typically less fluid is used.
Traditionally, liquid immersion cooling in the automotive industry has often been based on water-glycol mixtures, or just using water, which of course is naturally highly conductive and corrosive. As soon as water is introduced, the components to be cooled need to be within a sealed unit to prevent any risk of damage and this can limit the cooling efficiency since there is no direct contact with components; also, it imposes another set of design limitations on the electronics design engineer.
Immersion cooling with hydrocarbon-based fluids is another alternative and works well for many applications, but the flammability of this method puts a big question mark over its use in the automotive market. Plus, due to the typically low coefficient of thermal expansion in combination with high viscosity of oils, the convective properties are less favourable and a pump is more likely to be required to remove the heat efficiently from components. Also, the nature of oils makes repairs a messy process, not to mention the danger of exposing the application to flammable fluids should a leak occur.
More organisations in the automotive sector are now looking at the next generation of liquid immersion cooling, based on fluorinated specialty chemicals. These have the benefit of enabling direct contact, thus thermal management is comparatively fast and efficient. Plus, complete immersion is no problem, because no damage is caused to components and no residue remains should the fluid need to be removed in the future.
These fluids are non-corrosive, and there is often no need for ancillary equipment, so impact on battery footprint is reduced.
A final point to consider with any battery coolant is environmental legislation, which can have an impact on future use. With vehicle designers creating cars today that must have a shelf life for years to come, this is no small consideration. While dielectric specialty chemicals have their advantages, many are subject to legislative scrutiny. For example, HFCs, a commonly used chemical used in heat transfer applications, is being phased out under the F-gas regulation and, by 2030, will have reduced in manufacture and consumption by 79 per cent of today's usage.
However, the good news is that the use of some fluids is not affected by the F-gas regulation, such as HFE-based chemistries, offering significantly lower values of global warming potential, plus a short atmospheric lifetime and zero ozone depletion potential.
While the heat dissipation requirements of vehicle battery design is set to become even more demanding, the upside is that cooling innovation has kept pace.
Alexej Dens is a national account manager for the electronics and energy division at 3M
