Infotainment: Experience through design

A recent study reveals what consumers really want from their in-car display systems
This year marks the 30th anniversary of the first automotive touchscreen display. The 3 by 4in (7.7 by 10.2cm) monochrome display in the 1986 Buick Riviera wouldn’t win any awards today, but it turned out to be the start of something special. Now virtually every car on the road uses a display and a touch input of some sort as a key part of its in-car electronics.
These displays serve as a focal point for the car’s interior. They have grown dramatically in size and resolution over the past few years, with a switch to 4k seemingly on the horizon, but one of the most interesting trends is actually the use of multiple displays.
Alongside a large central screen, most cars now use the instrument cluster display. It’s also increasingly common to find a head up display (HUD), particularly on larger luxury cars. These look set to evolve into augmented reality in the near future, with virtual elements – such as arrows to highlight upcoming navigation steps – superimposed onto the field of vision.
Interestingly, it’s also likely that HUDs will spread to the passenger side in the future, which hints at a broadening role. For example, the Tesla Model 3 is rumoured to have a full-windshield display.
Along with these screens, many drivers now use the in-car electronics with an external smartphone, which brings its own apps and interfaces.
The question then is how best to divide tasks between the various display output screens. The central display can convey a lot of information and accommodate a lot of different touch points, but it’s potentially the most distracting to operate while driving. At the other end of the spectrum, drivers can read the HUD without taking their eyes off the road at all, and the cluster is almost as convenient, but neither can offer the same versatility as the main screen. So how do you prioritise the display of information?
Study
To investigate, automotive electronics and display systems supplier Harman conducted a focus group, composed of people who regularly leverage and interact with entertainment and navigation systems in their cars as well as their mobile devices. The group was split equally between those who tend to use the car’s built-in system and those who favour external mobile devices.
“It’s been a fascinating study,” said Rashmi Rao, head of advanced engineering at Harman. “This focus group helped us to understand how consumers approach multiple screens. We also gathered their opinions, thoughts and expectations for these systems in the future.”
One of the more unexpected findings from the study was that drivers actually interact remarkably little with the central screen while on the move. Given the choice, the participants prioritised the HUD and the cluster for most in-drive operations. In particular, the HUD was the preferred interface for incoming message alerts and short pieces of information relating to instantaneous and short notifications. The cluster was the favoured display for the car’s status, as well as more lengthy notifications and events happening in the immediate future. Meanwhile, the central display was reserved for more graphically intensive information such as maps, along with longer notifications and things happening further into the future as well as in some cases duplicating the information for the passenger’s use.
“Most of the participants wanted to see the next turn event – direction, distance and street name – on the HUD, and the same applied for text and incoming call notifications,” said Rao. “Half of them wanted to see a list of upcoming turn events on the cluster screen, two on HUD and only one on the centre screen. Interestingly, only one of them wanted to see information related to the current speed and maximum allowed speed on the HUD screen; the rest preferred to see it in the cluster.”
There are four core design principles for use during the in-car system design process to ensure there is a focus on users’ needs and expectations, reinforced by the findings of the focus group. The first principle is “glanceable content” where the user shouldn’t spend too much time exploring screens; the most important information should be available straight away. “Contextual” relates to information appearing when needed, with the system providing the right content based on each specific situation. “Safety first” ensures the user gets the information in the safest way possible while driving and it complies with NHTSA requirements. Lastly, “simplified” means being able to access different parts of the user interface in a consistent way to help users quickly understand new navigation and media concepts.
The study also raised some interesting points on the use of external smartphone apps for navigation. Participants who favoured smartphones said they could be faster and more accurate than in-car systems, with good quality mapping from the likes of Google. Ease of use, connectivity to their calendar and the ability to integrate live traffic alerts from apps such as Waze were also mentioned.
The biggest plus point identified for in-car navigation was less distraction. Participants said they found it safer and more reliable. It also avoids eating into their mobile bandwidth.
“We asked what it would take to get the smartphone users to switch back to their in-car navigation systems,” said Rao. “Better mapping, integration with their contacts and calendar, plus greater ease of use were all highlighted. Improved voice recognition and the ability to send pre-programmed routes direct to the system from their smartphone were some of the other observations.”
Another interesting point is that the participants were mostly open to the idea of a scribble pad. This is a virtual pad on the centre touchscreen that’s mirrored over to the HUD, allowing the user to scribble basic characters while driving. The idea is it could be linked to things such as contact lists and frequently used destinations to predict the word that was being entered within only a few characters.
These findings shed new light on the way people interact with their cars’ inputs and outputs. They may even give some hints as to novel interaction methods and user interfaces that could be deployed in cars in the next 30 years.
