Europe lags behind North America in ESC fitments

Frost & Sullivan

European car makers are lagging behind their North American counterparts in fitting electronic stability control (ESC) into new vehicles, according to a report from market watcher Frost & Sullivan. ESC is the most dominant enabler for active and passive safety technologies.

Built into a car, ESC can be crucial for avoiding crashes caused by losing control over the vehicle. But while the technology has achieved near complete penetration in North America, Europe still lags behind, which is mainly due to the lack of legislations mandating the technology in the region.

Despite the European NCap, which included tests to rate cars fitted with ESC from 2011, the technology has witnessed only minimal growth over the past two years.

According to Frost & Sullivan, the European ESC market is expected to reach a market value of close to €2bn by 2020. Among the various OEMs, it is the upper tiers in the pyramid that attract maximum fitment rates, with the German Big Three claiming close to 100% fitment across their eight segments.

"The mass market segments, though, work differently," said Frost & Sullivan industry analyst Arunprasad Nandakumar. "Across Europe, different OEMs have established varied strategies for marketing ESC for their portfolios. While the optional fitment costs the consumer anywhere between €300 and €1200, the average optional fitment rate is approximately €540 across Europe. If the technology does become mandatory in 2014, it will pose a challenge to volume manufacturers. They will either have to bear the cost of the technology or pass it on to the end consumer."

While mass market OEMs, such as Volkswagen and Toyota, follow a similar strategy by providing the technology as standard in 60 to 70% and as optional in the rest of their models, a few others, such as Fiat and Hyundai, have decided to offer the technology not even as optional on more than 3% of their entire product range.

Regarding rate diversity, Nissan and Renault, despite their existing alliance, serve another interesting case in point. While Renault incorporates the technology on a standard base of at least 80% of its line-up, Nissan only reaches 60%. But Renault sells about 1.6 times the volumes compared with Nissan in Europe, and the Japanese manufacturer may therefore be more sceptical to increase the cost of its products further, and thus counteract the effort to improve sales figures.

In addition, ESC fitment in Japan is still below that of Europe and North America, due to home-market legislation and few Japanese suppliers.

Also, American-owned Opel, a manufacturer offering the technology as standard across its portfolio in North America, only reaches 58% of fitment rates in Europe. While the standard fitment rate for Asian OEMs stands at 54% in Europe, European mass OEMs competing in the same segment are at 49%.

On top of that, countries such as Denmark, Sweden and Germany offer ESC fitment as standard in most models, while Greece, Malta and Iceland fail to offer the technology even as optional in most of the available models. Dealers operating in more than one European country fail to provide the technology equivalently. It is therefore not just the responsibility of a dealer to ensure favourable uptake of optional fitment; OEMs need to ensure availability across the vehicle model line-up, says the report.

"It is understandable that fitment rates are higher among premium OEMs in comparison to volume OEMs such as Fiat, Ford Europe and others who are faced with packaging challenges to incorporate an ESC into their existing models," said Nandakumar. "But the anomalies in fitment rates among various models within similar price brackets is a concern that automobile manufacturers need to assess."

The trend in fitment rates is expected to change as the technology is likely to become mandatory by September 2014, ensuring that all vehicle models manufactured since then will bear ESC as standard.

www.frost.com

Recommend to Colleagues: