Automotive radio tuners

Arthur Chan explains how to assess high-performance automotive radio tuners for infotainment systems
In-vehicle infotainment is a hot topic in the automotive world. At the heart of today’s sophisticated automotive infotainment platforms is a high-performance automotive radio tuner, an essential component that provides a state-of-art radio listening experience to drivers and passengers.
Automotive radio is a large market that continues to grow along with the increasing volume of automobiles being produced. In 2012, 84.1 million cars and commercial vehicles were manufactured worldwide. In the first six months of 2013, 44 million vehicles have already been produced. The size of the automotive aftermarket is many times larger as it is estimated that there are more than one billion vehicles on the road around the world.
Assuming each car has at least one radio and given the large market size, why are there only a few automotive radio tuner suppliers competing in this large and growing market?
Difficult market
The automotive tuner segment is a difficult semiconductor market to enter due to various reasons. Today’s complex, ever-changing driving environment requires high-performance radio tuner technology.
Automobiles are constantly on the move. This extreme mobility requires the automotive tuner to receive radio signals in a wide variety of reception conditions. Tuners must handle various types of signal impairments such as multipath generated by the broadcast signal reflected off mountains and buildings. The amplitude and phase of the resultant signal received also may change, leading to distortion and or loss of audio.
Weak signals occur in remote area affecting signal quality. Power lines and broadcast towers can transmit strong signals that interfere with the broadcast radio signal.
In-car interference
Inside the car, poor EMI shielding on electric motors running windshield wipers, windows, the sunroof and other body and cabin components, and even the engine and horn, can cause interference. Improper antenna connections can also produce interference. Additional interference can come from the car radio PCB where DC-DC converters, large LCD panels and other high-speed digital circuitry are housed.
Competitive pressures require tuner IC companies to supply tuners with higher integration and with no compromise in performance.
Traditional tuners were manufactured in bi-cmos technologies a generation ago. With today’s mounting pressure to reduce cost, RF tuner design has migrated to cost-effective cmos technologies at foundries such as TSMC to achieve lower cost mixed-signal integration at deep sub-micron nodes. Only a few tuner suppliers in the world can perform advanced low-cost RF cmos design of digital low-IF architecture for radio tuners.
To serve the automotive OEM market, a tuner IC supplier typically must be an ISO/TS16949-certified company, providing AEC-Q100-qualified tuner ICs.
Automotive tuner suppliers must have a global presence to provide on-site support worldwide for design and test drives. RF PCB layout and automotive test drives require local support to shorten design cycles and facilitate radio tuning during test drives.
The combination of these success factors results in a high barrier to entry that permits only a few semiconductor companies to supply tuners to the global automotive infotainment market.
Tuner requirements
A strong suite of key performance parameters and features is required to overcome the challenging environment in which automotive radio tuners operate. These parameters include excellent sensitivity to pull in a weak signal.
If you live in a rural area far away from the transmitters of most radio stations, the sensitivity of a tuner will be of great importance. A good tuner with -3.5dBµV sensitivity can pull in a signal at 0.5µV extending its ability to tune in to a station up to 160km away.
Selectivity refers to a tuner's ability to receive a weak station in the presence of stronger stations at small frequency offsets. This is especially important for receivers in crowded FM spectrums in urban environments. Adjacent channel selectivity, which refers to suppression of signals ±100kHz away from the tuned frequency, is important in European markets as the adjacent channel blockers can be as close as ±100kHz for FM broadcast in border regions.
A high-performance automotive tuner should have at least 65dB selectivity with ±100kHz blockers. Some tuners can achieve this selectivity with a powerful state-of-the-art radio DSP algorithm that dynamically optimises the desired channel bandwidth by gauging several signal metrics including adjacent and alternate channel conditions, narrowing the channel bandwidth in the presence of strong blockers.
IP3 is a figure-of-merit measure of a tuner’s linearity. Higher IP3 means better linearity and less distortion. The most severe distortion is third-order inter-modulation (IMD3) distortion resulting from two close-in blockers that show up on-channel on the desired station (see diagram). In crowded FM spectrums, very common in urban markets, the blockers are too close to the desired spectrum to be easily filtered out.
To reduce third-order distortion products, IP3 performance must be increased. Tuners with low IP3 will require very expensive high Q tracking filters to avoid IMD3 break-in, an extremely unpleasant experience to the listener. A leading automotive tuner will have an IP3 of 117dBµV coupled with sensitivity at -3.5dBµV at full RF gain. It should also provide a very wide IMD dynamic range to offer protection against IMD3 break-in with no external filtering blocks.
In Europe, AF is a choice that allows the car radio tuner to tune to a different frequency that provides the same station, when the first signal becomes too weak when moving out of range. This is often used in European car radio systems, enabled by RDS where the AF list is transmitted via RDS data. In higher end cars, a dedicated background companion tuner is used to scan the AF list providing AF station metrics to the host to decide when to jump to the AF station when the primary station becomes compromised.
In cost-sensitive radios (in which two tuners are too expensive) the primary audio tuner is tuned to the AF station to qualify the AF station and re-tuned to the primary station without causing a perceptible break in the audio. The maximum time accepted in executing the AF check operation is under 10ms. Most tuners in the market are able only to qualify the AF station’s received signal strength indication (RSSI). Top-performing automotive tuners are able to perform an AF check operation at 6ms or less and qualify not one but four station metrics, including RSSI, SNR, frequency offset and multipath interference.
Multipath interference is the bane of FM radio reception in mobile environments especially at high speeds. Multipath distortion is caused when two or more radio signals broadcast from the same source arrive at a receiver at different times and with different phases and attenuation levels due to reflections of the signal from various objects.
The radio signal prior to arriving at the receiver can experience changes in amplitude and phase due to two types of multipath fading: flat and frequency-selective. In urban environments, reflections from close-in objects such as buildings result in short delay multipath fading, causing wideband deep fades. In this scenario all spectral components of the signal experience amplitude attenuation simultaneously (flat fading), leading to harsh audio pops and drop outs. In turn, long multipath delay (frequency-selective fading) arises due to reflections from objects several kilometres away such as distant hills and tall buildings. In this scenario certain spectral components will be attenuated causing deep notches in the channel leading to audio distortion.
The traditional approach is to mitigate the effects of multipath with techniques such as blending back to mono audio from full stereo audio, deploying low pass audio filters (high-cut and high-blend), attenuating the audio level when there are harsh pops due to severe multipath and soft muting as the last resort. Automotive tuners should have the above basic mitigation engines run autonomously, activated and monitored by signal quality metrics continuously.
A good automotive tuner should have an FM channel equaliser to cancel frequency selective multipath fading, thus yielding audio with low distortion. The equaliser’s adaptation algorithm continuously seeks to restore spectral components attenuated due to frequency-selective fading effects, thus restoring the signal even as the vehicle travels through multiple fading situations. The result is reduced audio distortion and a lower level of sound-compromising mitigation applied to the audio, such as stereo-mono blend and high-cut and high-blend.
FM phase diversity
In recent years, European automotive OEMs such as BMW, Audi, VW and Daimler have adopted glass and patch active antenna systems, moving away from passive whip rod antennas. However, with small glass antennas, FM radio reception becomes compromised. With dual antenna and phase diversity tuner systems, OEMs circumvent the issue by combining two antennas to provide more signal strength and significantly improved resistance to multi-path fading.
Dual-tuner phase diversity systems with channel equalisation can be implemented with leading automotive tuners to address both flat and frequency-selective fading, whereby the dual tuner outputs are combined to alleviate fading to improve audio quality greatly.
In an antenna phase diversity system, the RF signal is received by two uncorrelated antennas spaced at an optimum distance from each other, and they are connected to two tuners tuned to the same frequency. The signal propagation path at one antenna location may experience a deep fade while the other signal propagation path at the other antenna location does not.
Dual-tuner antenna phase diversity systems provide the capability to combine the multiple antenna outputs to reduce poor signal reception due to flat fading. The two receivers use a common reference clock to ensure they are tuned to the same channel frequency to stream the IF signal and associated signal quality metrics from one receiver denoted the secondary receiver to the other denoted as the primary receiver. The two IF signals are phase aligned and combined in the primary receiver using proprietary phase diversity algorithms. The combined IF signal is subsequently channel equalised, FM demodulated, MPX decoded and signal conditioned in the primary receiver. The output is stereo audio to an audio signal processing unit in the system.
HD radio
HD radio digital radio broadcast is gaining traction in automotive radios in the USA. Previously relegated to high-end cars, HD radio is now moving into mid-range platforms for the American market. Automotive OEMs that have adopted HD radio include Ford, Volvo and BMW. Several more OEMs are moving to wider adoption in the immediate future. It is estimated that by 2015 well over half of all cars shipping in the USA will have HD radio reception. The HD tuner must be certified by IBiquity, the developer and licenser of HD radio technology for automotive OEM grade AM and FM tuner performance.
Looking to the future
Infotainment system developers are demanding ever-higher quality of automotive radio performance at a lower system cost. Today’s consumers also expect a CD-quality audio experience from their car radios.
Automotive OEMs and tier-one suppliers understand this trend and are responding by designing sophisticated infotainment systems that incorporate the latest automotive tuners that deliver superior sensitivity and selectivity, excellent IP3 performance and FM phase diversity reception while supporting digital radio standards such as HD radio technology.
Automotive tuners with excellent performance and cost benefit are being adopted by automotive OEMs and tier-one infotainment system suppliers in mass production projects now. These advanced automotive tuners have set a new benchmark in price and performance value for automotive customers while enabling a superior in-vehicle audio experience for consumers.
Arthur Chan is senior product marketing manager for Silicon Labs
